Tia Vs. Asuka Kirara, an empirical AV face-down
In this week’s crazy idea I’m comparing Tia and Asuka Kirara. Two top-notch JAV actresses with somewhat similar careers. They also share similar levels of popularity, plus they both acted during the same era for S1 STYLE ONE studio for a long time. Hence, with so many similarities this comparison makes sense.
They are similar yet so different. For example accounting personality. They are completely different. Tia is more cold and bitchy. Kirara is more sociable.
So, I will compare them in several aspects and give a point to whoever is better. Our first ever epic JAV face-off. 🙂
Tia (ティア). AGE 26
Asuka Kirara (明日花キララ). AGE 29
1. Best looks Right now, at the time of writing:
Winner = Asuka Kirara
Tia amazing looks declined at the speed of light. And that, being 3 years younger than Kirara. Then to round it all up, she did a trip to Korea to destroy her own face.
The clear winner is Kirara here. Although our beloved Asuka is also guilty of “almost” wrecking her own face via surgery. 🙂
Asuka Kirara in her latest AV work. Let’s not talk about how Tia looks now…
2. Best looks at their peak:
Winner = Tia
Ok, this was a tough one. Kirara on peak had a really explosive and tight body too. Almost a tie, but, in my opinion, when Tia was Super-Tia, she was just a couple steps above everyone else. Her body when she was slightly chubby and blonde is killer. Hard to compete on that. One of the best ever and she wins here.
Tia, when she was at her best, was really too much.
3. Best acting skills
Winner = Asuka Kirara
Kirara wins again here by a lot. I think she is miles better actress than Tia. More charismatic and funny. Kirara can speak better. Has a better personality. Is more beloved. There is 0 competition regarding this.
Tia was also kind of hated in the Muscats show, and she hated to act there. Nothing compared to Kirara.
4. Best Himekano: Asuka SNIS-951 vs. Tia EBOD-458
Winner = Tia
Tia Himekano makes more sense and is hotter. Almost a tie here though.
About Kirara SNIS-951 many have criticized her for being too plasticky and over the top in this JAV.
What can I say, I liked Kirara Himekano too. It was more fun also.
Tia Himekano was somewhat better. Asuka version is much more weird, yet funny.
5. Tia SNIS-340 Vs Kirara SNIS-381 (Forced to model lingerie S1 gimmick)
Winner = A Tie
No clear winner for me here, and probably these two are best JAV titles on this whole post.
When Tia and Kirara coincided in S1 STYLE ONE studio, they acted in two (insanely hot) AV with the same gimmick. Good for comparison 🙂
SNIS-381 is one of my favorites ever. But then again SNIS-340 is so good that comes on par. Considering that they are both done by the same studio almost at the same time is not surprising.
I can’t give a winner here. I’m slightly inclined to give Tia as a winner. But Kirara’s SNIS-340 has some of the best scenes ever. Nah. These 2 titles are the balls. It’s a freakin’ tie 🙂 🙂 🙂
6. Tia SNIS-136 Vs. Kirara SNIS-075 (S1 gimmick, My hot life with…)
Winner = Tia
I truly dislike Kirara face in SNIS-075.
A very easy win for Tia here.
7. Kirara SNIS-172 VS Tia SNIS-238 (Sensual masseuse gimmick)
Winner = Asuka Kirara
This blonde Tia is my favorite. And it’s hard to beat her. But I feel Kirara’s SNIS-172 carried much more punch. And by this time, her face was improving fast. Kirara wins here.
8. Tia SNIS-035 VS Kirara SNIS-576 (Not same series, but same gimmick= Flight attendants)
Winner = Tia
How do you beat a Tia with this body? And she even deep-throats. WTF.
With that said, The SNIS-576 (Note: I have posted this JAV English subbed as-well) from Kirara is super good too. Almost a tie.
9. Kirara SNIS-191 Vs Tia SOE-982 (Girls looking for molesters)
Winner = Asuka Kirara
Yet almost another tie. I liked Tia blonde hair in SOE-982, her body is good as always and she does a solid work
But Kirara’s SNIS-191 carried so much punch and good scenes. Slightly better.
10. Tia SOE-935 Vs Kirara SOE-960 (Exclusive S1 Debut)
Winner = Tia
Tia S1 debut was top-notch and so awesome. Kirara SOE-960 debut for S1 was kind of meh.
Easy point for Tia.
11. Tia SNIS-300 vs Kirara SNIS-360 (Life Insurance Sales Lady)
Winner= A Tie.
I find it hard to pick a winner here. Kirara as OL shines in here though.
12. Kirara SNIS-484 Vs Tia SNIS-427 (Gaping pussy series)
Winner = Asuka Kirara
Once again, Tia did a decent job on this JAV release. The nurse attire looked good on her.
But Kirara completely destroyed her.
Kirara won this easily.
Final score
Kirara 6 VS 6 Tia, and 2 ties.
The empirical score does not lie, It’s a tie 🙂 Bite me.
This is surprising to me too, I thought Tia would get slaughtered by Kirara. But results probably are inflated by her SNIS titles, which were pretty good tbh. Better than those from Kirara.(Just my opinion).
My personal and final take
Regardless of this, Asuka Kirara is, for me, the better JAV superstar.
We could exclude a (short) period of time, in which blonde Tia was virtually the most attractive AV girl around. However, that didn’t last long.
With that said old Tia was so epic, she will be missed. Asuka Kirara has been aging surprisingly well, and she looks really good right now.
As a final note, I like that both actresses climbed their way to the top from very shitty studios. 2 very different and good actresses that made themselves up.
My result is 10-4 for Asuka Kirara.
Considering that Asuka is my favorite, the 4 points of Tia are not bad.
I like this idea of comparing two stars. It would be nice if I continued it. But even among girls from different studies it would be nice. You could choose standard aspects to analyze like the body, acting skill, AV debut, if they have videos with the same gimmick etc.
Correct. Some girls are very comparable. Especially those who do the exact videos often.
Another example is Kojima Minami vs. Amatsuka Moe.
Exact! Speaking of Asuka Kirara, did you see the preview of the February release? It seems to be back in full production.
I looked at all the preview and that of Aoi Tsukasa disappointed me because I did not really like his look. I do not know if it is a thing of now or if it was also in that of last month but her breasts is not natural at all.
Haha yes. Seems Aoi got a breast enhancement. Great find.
The new SSNI-103 =
This is SNIS-989 =
I for one don’t care she didn’t have any boobs before. I was more into her pretty face and slender body. Plus her usual good acting.
PS: I think the new Asuka Kirara release will be very good. Although I don’t fully like her new hairstyle. But she looks good.
Yua Mikami and Minami Kana releases will be also very good. I’m very impressed with Minami.
The fact is that from the video preview the movement of the breasts is ugly, not at all natural.
Of the videos of February, the videos I’m waiting for are: Asuka Kirara, Mikami Yua, Minato Riku, Kano Yura and Hinana Hanon.
In the end I will watch them all, then also Aoi Tsukasa, Minami Kana, Kojima Minami, Usa Miharu, Yoshizawa Akiho, Amatsuka Moe, Yoshitaka Nene… in short, they have a dream harem.
Big fan of Kiara <3
Good read. I totally agree with you
Kirara has this weird charm and charismatic personality that make people fall in love with her. she can act and sing a rap song (lol) she’s also the smartest diva in this industry. such a shame she’ll be 31 this year and might go retired. anyway hope she’ll find a good husband and live happily ever after.
As of 2021 kirara remains the queen here~
Kirara still takes home the gold 2023